Blog

  • Should Great Danes have Grain Free Food?

    Should Great Danes have Grain Free Food?

    For Centuries, humans have continually adjusted and tailored dietary guidelines to align with the latest trends, science, and research. The current fad of excluding grains, carbs, and processed foods from human diets has extended to pet foods, with grain-free options gaining popularity. However, the decision is more complex when it comes to whether Great Danes should have grain free food or not.

    You may have heard from your veterinarian, a friend, or on social media that grain-free or boutique (“BEG”) foods are bad for Great Danes. Alternatively, you may have heard that grain-free kibbles are “higher quality”, have “more meat”, and can help resolve allergies.

    It’s hard to know what to do when you hear so many conflicting opinions, so here at Hello Danes we’re going to run with science.

    In the interest of saving you some time here, I will cut to the chase. Of course, we’re going to deep dive into this below, but here is the low down: most, if not all, grain-free kibbles are a bad choice to feed your Great Dane.

    The information in this blog post is important and may save your dogs life!

    12

    The Problem with Grain-Free Dog Food

    All extruded kibbles require some kind of starch to bind the meat together. Without it, the food would be dust.

    In grain-inclusive dog foods, this starch is often some form of rice or oats.

    In grain-free dog foods, grains are replaced most often with ingredients such as peas, lentils, and potatoes. These are starchy carbohydrates that may also be used to replace meat-based protein.

    (A benefit of ingredients such as rice, oats, or lentils is that they add fiber to your dog’s diet, which may decrease the risk of bloat. )

    Grain-free foods are NOT carb-free! Lentils, peas, and potatoes have lots of carbohydrates.

    Now it’s also important to understand that ‘Fresh meat’ is roughly 70% water and doesn’t have the same robust nutritional profile that bone, organ meat, and cartilage has.

    Compare that to a concentrated meat meal or meat by-product meal (which sounds gross, but is made of bone, organ, tissue, and cartilage), and is packed with protein and amino acids. Meat meals are only 10% water.

    Many grain-free kibbles after extrusion, especially those with ‘fresh meat’ and multiple starch sources, are nothing more than meat-flavored peas or lentils.

    Even if you personally see no correlation between grain-free dog food and DCM (more on this below), you have to admit this is a huge problem.

    3 2

    What is DCM in Dogs?

    Now for the fun part.

    Grain-free and improperly balanced or pulse (legume) heavy boutique brand foods are implicated in a notable increase of deadly DCM (heart problems) in pet dogs.

    By implicated, we mean that there is a strong correlation that is actively being studied. Check out any veterinary or breed-specific group and you will see stories of dogs dying this way. Lots of them.

    DCM (aka ‘Dilated Cardiomyopathy) is a devastating disease that results in an enlarged heart. The larger heart has to work harder to pump blood and as a result, the valves can leak.

    Over time, the heart cannot keep up.

    Fluid builds up in the chest and abdomen and eventually, the heart will give out.

    Left untreated, many dogs eventually suffer from congestive heart failure and will die, often suddenly.

    Unfortunately, DCM is often a ‘silent killer’, often undetected until it is too late.

    Great Danes are genetically prone to DCM (deadly heart problems), especially if the breeder isn’t fully health-testing the parents. So their risk of developing DCM is even higher than it is for other dogs.

    Many people have what they think are ‘perfectly healthy’ young Great Danes with shiny coats and perfect stools. These dogs die suddenly while sleeping or playing.

    Some of them have genetic DCM.

    Many of them have secondary DCM, however. This is caused by unbalanced, poorly formulated food and nutrient deficiency.

    Read on…

    A Tasty Top: The Top 11 Foods to Feed a Great Dane

    Great Dane Not Eating- What to Do

    How Much Do Great Danes Eat?

    13

    Signs of DCM Heart Disease in Dogs

    DCM often presents with no symptoms, especially secondary DCM.

    Secondary DCM is seen in dogs who are fed incorrect and unbalanced nutrition.

    An echocardiogram is needed to diagnose DCM/Dilated Cardiomyopathy.

    To be clear, a regular ‘vet check’ does not rule out nutrition and diet-related heart problems.

    If you are feeding a boutique or grain-free diet, it is recommended that you get an echocardiogram for your dog.

    Symptoms of more advanced stage DCM in dogs include:

    • Coughing
    • Lethargy
    • Anorexia
    • Labored Breathing
    • Rapid breathing when resting or sleeping
    • Distended belly
    • Weight loss
    • Depression
    • Lowered activity
    • Sudden death

    https://vcahospitals.com/know-your-pet/dilated-cardiomyopathy-dcm-in-dogs–indepth

    How is DCM Treated?

    Once a dog is diagnosed with primary (genetic) or secondary (nutrition-related) DCM, or the early signs of it, things must happen quickly.

    The veterinarian will typically:

    • Recommend that the diet is immediately changed to food that meets WSAVA guidelines
    • Prescribe medications and supplements if needed
    • Encourage certain restrictions to exercise
    • Give you a list of signs and symptoms to watch for that indicate worsening Dilated Cardiomyopathy or congestive heart failure

    4-6 months later, the dog will be checked again via echocardiogram.

    For dogs with primary DCM (genetic), the condition may not improve.

    With secondary DCM (nutrition-based), assuming that the condition was caught soon enough and the dog was switched to a properly formulated science-backed food, improvement is often noted. Some dogs go on to live full, normal lives.

    Great Dane Nutrition: Puppy vs. Adult Food

    How do I Fix my Dog’s Upset Stomach?

    Our List of the Best Foods for Great Danes, 2022

    20

    Why do vets not recommend grain-free food?

    A large majority of food-related DCM cases go undocumented.

    Many dogs pass suddenly of a ‘heart attack’, during anesthesia, or in their sleep. Expensive (and often heartbreaking) post-mortem testing for it isn’t always done.

    Great Danes do have a genetic predisposition to primary DCM that may be at play here.

    This makes it even more important to be informed about the roll that diet may play, and to ensure that all breeders are thoroughly testing their dogs (OFA Heart / Echocardiograms, etc.) prior to breeding.

    If you feed grain-free, are thinking about feeding grain-free OR are ‘on the fence’ about this debate, read on.

    4 1

    Should Great Danes eat Grain-Free food?

    The potential link between grain-free foods and DCM was brought to the attention of the FDA when Veterinary Cardiologists were noticing an increase of suspicious heart problems in dogs.

    Secondary DCM was showing up at an alarming rate; higher than the typical genetic incidence, and they were growing concerned.

    Their investigation revealed (and still reveals to date) that an alarming majority (90%) of the dogs experiencing secondary DCM were being fed boutique dog foods.

    Kibbles from small dog food companies such as Fromm’s, Orijen, Diamond, Victor, Nutrisource, 4Health, and Acana are taking the brunt of this potential correlation, primarily because among ’boutique’ and smaller food brands they have the largest market share.

    More fed dogs = more sick dogs.

    But there are 1000’s of brands and formulas on the market. Not being on that list doesn’t magically make a diet “safe”, and consider this:

    Purina, Royal Canin and Hill’s feed more dogs than any other brands. Purina alone leads the market with over 16 billion in revenue (2021, and growing).

    That’s a lot of dogs. Many more than are fed Fromm, Victor, or otherwise and yet…the millions of Purina-fed dogs are not turning up with nutritional-DCM.

    The fact that any are turning up at all in smaller brands is alarming.

    Since the time of the original DCM reports, the grain-free DCM debate has become a hotbed of opinions, frustration, and concern between professionals, credentialed nutritionists, raw feeding enthusiasts, and dog owners.

    At Hello Danes, we believe that a grain-free food from a small company, that has a lot of peas, lentils, legumes, or potatoes in the ingredients list is dangerous to feed.

    People don’t want to hear that the food they believed to be ‘holistic’ and ‘high quality’ may actually be killing their beloved pet. It’s easy to want to believe that something more ‘natural’ is best, but it’s not always the case, unfortunately.

    DCM Groups to Join on Facebook:

    The following groups have tons of information from real dog owners and veterinarians:

    Pet Vet Corner: https://www.facebook.com/groups/337421456457048

    Canine: Nutrition and Dog Food Discussion: https://www.facebook.com/groups/551782614843296

    Diet Associated DCM in Dogs: https://www.facebook.com/groups/1952593284998859

    10 1

    Does adding taurine to Grain-Free food prevent DCM?

    In response to the FDA warnings about DCM and grain-free dog food, people began to believe that adding taurine or grains to a dog’s diet would solve the problem.

    This concept doesn’t actually have science to back it up; it was only a theory that as of this writing still has no merit.

    Regardless, many boutique manufacturers responded by adding taurine to their formulation. They then took the opportunity to market their brand as being ‘scientific and thoughtful’.

    Of the DCM cases being studied by the FDA, many of the dogs suffering from DCM had normal taurine levels.

    If there is any merit or science behind a taurine-DCM link, current research is indicating that it’s likely related to formulation problems in the food that may be blocking the synthesis and bioavailability of taurine.

    In other words; adding taurine isn’t likely to solve a problem that originated with a poorly-formulated diet to begin with.

    You can’t supplement your way out of a bad diet.

    Dr. Jennifer Larson, Veterinary Nutritionist U.C. Davis

    Does adding grains to dog food prevent DCM?

    Adding grains (such as rice or oats) at home to a grain-free kibble only serves to further unbalance the food and load the dog up on carbs.

    This too has been done with no scientific backing. Doing so is not safe, effective or healthy.

    Do not add rice, millet, oats, or other grains to your Danes boutique diet to ‘prevent DCM’. There is no science behind that theory at all, and it may do more harm than good.

    Additionally, choosing the ‘grain-inclusive’ version of a boutique dog food brand does not make it magically ‘safe’.

    Nutritional DCM has been seen in dogs on boutique diets of all kinds, both grain-inclusive and grain-free.

    Read here about how my own Great Dane Matilda nearly died from nutritional imbalance related to a boutique ‘holistic’ dog food.

    20

    Is a Grain-Free Diet ok for dogs?

    While ‘grain-free’ foods and boutique brands specifically have been implicated, it is believed that the problem may actually originate with boutique kibbles that are formulated with a lot of pulse, legumes, peas and potatoes.

    Remember, many Grain-free kibbles heavily utilize peas, pulses, lentils, garbanzo beans and potatoes in their formulation.

    In other words, just as the FDA stated (see below) that it’s not necessarily grain-free that is the problem, it’s boutique foods that are:

    • Heavy in pulses, peas, potatoes, and legumes
    • Not formulated by an on-staff board-certified Veterinary Nutritionist
    • Manufactured by brands that don’t participate in peer-reviewed science, research and feeding trials

    Many of these types of diets tend to be grain-free.

    So can Great Danes have grain-free foods? Sure, but should they? Probably NOT.

    When you read something that says ‘the FDA finds no evidence that grain-free diets cause heart disease‘, don’t immediately jump to the conclusion that your ‘grain-free boutique kibble’ is safe.

    Read that statement for what it is. It’s not the lack of grains that is the problem.

    It’s the replacement of essential meat-based amino acids and proteins with pulses, peas, potatoes, legumes, and other plant-based carbohydrates, often done by boutique brands with no board-certified veterinary nutritionist on staff to formulate, research and test the food.

    Research is ongoing and all of us should be alarmed, not defensive.

    Read the Label on your Dog Food Bag

    Read the ingredients list on the back of your grain-free kibble, ‘fresh’ or ‘human-grade’ dog food bag. Do you notice a lot of the following? It may be worth changing your dog’s diet as a precaution, especially if you noticed multiple forms of the same ingredient (aka, Ingredient Splitting).

    • Peas, Pea protein, Pea Starch, Pea Fiber, Pea Flour
    • Potatoes, Potato Protein, Potato Starch, Potato Fiber, Potato Flour
    • Sweet Potatoes
    • Lentils, Green Lentils, Red Lentils, Dried Lentils, Fresh Lentils, Whole Lentils
    • Garbanzo Beans, Chickpeas, Chickpea Flour, Chickpea Fiber
    • Other similar non-grain ingredients including pulses and legumes

    We also recommend avoiding the following dog food brands altogether (this list is not exhaustive).

    Despite making up only a small market share of dog food sold, these brands (and brands like them) are responsible for 100% of nutrition-related DCM cases (and likely many, many more health conditions including chronic loose stools, itching, hyper or hypocalcemia, growth disorders and more):

    • Fromm
    • Victor
    • 4Health
    • Diamond Naturals
    • Costco
    • Nulo
    • Nutro
    • Nutrisource
    • Earthborn Holistic
    • Acana
    • Orijen
    • Zignature
    • Solid Gold

    As pet owners, we don’t have enough professional knowledge to evaluate ingredients list pros and cons.

    Here is a great article on why judging food by the ingredients list is an amateur mistake!

    We tend to default to what ‘feels right’ or ‘seems healthy’, especially when boutique food companies use catchy, unregulated words such as ‘holistic’ and ‘super-premium’.

    14

    What are ’boutique dog food diets’?

    Boutique food diets for dogs come from small companies that use catchy terms in their marketing.

    New research (in 2022) indicates that the DCM and Grain-Free foods issue correlates STRONGLY to boutique food brands where no board-certified veterinary nutritionist is on staff to formulate the foods.

    Hallmark traits of boutique dog food diets:

    • Offers very little if any contribution to canine nutrition, health and veterinary research
    • Does not support veterinary nutrition, health and research organizations (such as WSAVA)
    • Does not participate in full, legitimate AAFCO feeding trials to prove formulations
    • Only formulates their food to ‘meet the nutritional requirements’ on paper
    • Does not employ a board-certified Veterinary Nutritionist to formulate the food; may ‘contract’ with a professional that has lesser degrees
    • May or may not own and operate their own manufacturing facilities
    • May use ‘exotic’ ingredients with very little research behind them, including kangaroo, bison and unusual carbohydrates such as millet.

    https://www.docofalltrades.net/2022/04/randomized-feeding-trial-in-labradors

    Here are some catchy terms meant to make you feel ‘good’ about the food:

    • Holistic
    • Human Grade
    • Added Taurine
    • All Natural
    • Guaranteed Health
    • Family-owned
    • Super-Premium
    • ‘No Recalls’
    • ‘No Fillers’
    • ‘Fresh’
    • ‘Ancient Grains’

    Here is a great article about boutique dog foods from the Burlington Vet Center: https://burlingtonvetctr.com/boutique-exotic-and-grain-free-pet-foods-and-their-link-to-heart-disease

    Boutique dog foods

    The following brands are just some of the popular boutique dog foods. Check these brands against the manufacturer report above and see how they rate.

    • Victor
    • Nulo
    • Diamond
    • Costco/Kirkland
    • Fromm
    • Nutro
    • 4 Health
    • Roosevelt
    • Life’s Abundance
    • Nutrisource
    • Olly
    • The Farmer’s Dog
    • Earthborn Holistic
    • Ketona
    • Spot and Tango

    The problem with boutique dog food marketing

    When you start looking into it, you may be surprised to find that MANY boutique kibble brands do not employ a legitimate, board-certified veterinary nutritionist to formulate, research, test and update their foods.

    As a matter of fact, a lot of ‘natural’ kibble brands only appear healthier because of their impressive dedication to packaging and marketing.

    FROMM, for example, is a brand that has been implicated many times in DCM. There have been many Fromm-related cases where dogs had their secondary DCM symptoms reversed by switching to a more professionally formulated diet.

    FROMM family foods are formulated by a chemical engineer; not somebody with a credible background in actual nutrition and current research. But their marketing makes you belief in their ‘family owned’ mission of ‘healthy’ nutrition.

    There are more dogs, more dogs eating kibble and more veterinary resources at our disposal now; so it stands to reason that this has always been a problem, but we are just now starting to really see it.

    DCM is often a silent killer. MANY dogs will die suddenly of a ‘heart attack’ without warning. In this case, owners rarely seek answers (a post-mortem autopsy is expensive) and as a result, DCM is never diagnosed or tied to the food that had been fed.

    5

    Is the Dog Food Advisor Blog a good place to learn about dog food?

    Many people reference the dog food advisor blog for nutrition information for their pets.

    The owner of that blog is a human dentist with no background in veterinary nutrition.

    The rating system is made up.

    We can do so much better than this when choosing large breed dry dog food for our beloved dogs, right?

    What is the best dog food for Great Danes 2021-2022?

    After much research into this ourselves, we believe that if you are going to feed kibble you should choose a brand that is fully backed by top-level research and veterinary nutritionists.

    The best dry food for Great Dane dogs is going to be backed by research and science, not opinions and marketing.

    When choosing a dry dog food diet for your Great Dane, of course, you will want to choose something that you feel good feeding!

    Look past the ingredients list and research the company itself.

    • Do they employ a dedicated, on-staff board certified veterinary nutritionist (ACVN or DACVN)?
    • Do they manufacture the food in-house, from carefully sourced, chosen, and tested ingredients?
    • Do they participate in university-level research and nutrition study for the advancement of companion animal health?
    • Do their foods undergo AAFCO feeding trials, or are they just formulated to meet minimums on paper?
    • Do they support the non-profit World Small Animal Veterinary Association (WSAVA) or give you reasons why they don’t?

    Marketing has unfortunately taught us that the heavily researched, professionally formulated science-backed dog food brands such as Purina, Royal Canin, and Eukanuba are ‘full of fillers and cancer-causing junk‘. ,

    That couldn’t be farther from the truth.

    Take note of the people you tend to hear that kind of misinformation from; none of them have any credible, boarded, science-backed veterinary background in canine nutrition. None. Most stand to gain, financially, from making you believe these things, too. Follow the money!

    Millions of dollars of actual health and nutrition-based research are done by the ‘Big 5’ brands, who use that information to formulate and then fully test the foods that they sell.

    Millions of dogs are eating these brands every single day and living long, healthy lives too! As a matter of fact, Pro Plan and Royal Canin are the foods of choice for a large majority of top breeders and dog sports competitors, not to mention veterinarians and millions of dog owners.

    We recommend Purina Pro Plan, however, a large or giant breed formula (puppy or adult, depending on your dog) from any of the following brands is an acceptable choice: Purina, Eukanuba, Iams, Hills, Royal Canin.

    The best dog foods for Great Danes:

    Check out THE GIANT DOG FOOD PROJECT to compare brands and values.

    9 1

    Vet recommended dog food for Great Danes

    The majority of veterinarians in the U.S. are going to recommend one of the following brands of food:

    • Purina
    • Royal Canin
    • Eukanuba
    • Iams
    • Hill’s Science Diet

    Some people will argue that veterinarians have very little nutrition education and that their education comes from companies that incentivize them to take the class and promote their food.

    Then it is believed that the veterinarians stand to profit from the sale of foods in their office and are making tons of money marketing these ‘billion-dollar cancer nuggets’.

    Let’s dig deeper into that!

    a. The companies sponsoring nutrition classes at the top veterinary schools are the same companies that spend millions on nutrition research and canine health science. They know a lot more about canine nutrition than boutique food brands, so if our vets are going to learn about nutrition, it should probably be from them right?

    b. A veterinarian that has taken a few nutrition classes during the course of their study has still learned a lot more about canine nutrition than somebody who sells pet food at a boutique pet store. For some reason, people are more willing to listen to a sales rep with 7 days of training or a dog trainer than to somebody with a studied, professional veterinary background!

    c. Some veterinarians go on to obtain additional certifications in canine nutrition. Every single one of these highly-studied veterinarians will still recommend the science-backed and heavily researched food brands listed above and no, they often don’t make a dime on those recommendations. Kickbacks are actually ILLEGAL in the U.S.

    d. Veterinarians are often approached by companies to market food brands and make brand recommendations. There is a reason we don’t see veterinarians promoting boutique brands for affiliate income (even though they totally could); they simply don’t believe in those foods.

    e. If a veterinarian profits from the sale of science-backed, professionally formulated dog food, why is that so bad? The boutique pet store profits too from selling you ‘healthy and holistic’ pet food diets made by companies with no nutrition research backing their food.

    There are plenty of opportunities for veterinarians to use affiliate links to promote ’boutique’ food brands. They don’t, though. Ever think about why that is?

    You’ll notice that we use affiliate links in our promotion of certain food brands. We could choose any brand to promote!

    Do we make a few pennies if you purchase through our affiliate link? Sure. Anytime you buy food, somebody will profit no matter what.

    Question if the people you are listening to are promoting that food because it’s backed by actual science, or because it’s backed by opinion and boutique marketing.

    The truth here is that boutique food brands earn millions by using marketing, fancy words, and pretty packaging to make you believe that the unproven, untested food they make is healthier.

    The food-profit incentive is not isolated to veterinarians who make pennies on the sale of a bag of food. Stop blaming that. Everybody profits somewhere. Put your money where the science is.

    (Your breeder may profit from the promotion of certain foods, such as Life’s Abundance, an MLM pyramid scheme food with no science behind it!)

    17

    Homemade dog food for Great Danes

    Regarding Home Cooked Diets:

    Pinterest and a crock pot full of overcooked meat, veggies and rice is NOT balanced nor is it magically healthier for your pet.

    If you are planning to home cook meals for your dog, work with a credentialed, studied veterinary nutritionist to develop a recipe specifically for your pet.

    You can search for a veterinary nutritionist HERE: https://acvn.org/directory/

    You may hear from dog trainers or ‘holistic’ pet care professionals that cooking food at home is the healthiest choice, however these people don’t have expertise in canine nutrition.

    Below we’ve linked our favorite resources for learning more about homemade feeding.

    HOME COOKED FEEDING RESOURCES

    Balance It

    Pet Diets

    Note that anybody can pick up the ‘nutritionist’ title. Being a dog or ‘nutrition’ enthusiast, or working in a pet store as a brand rep or salesperson does not make somebody an expert.

    Look for University level degrees & certifications in canine nutrition, not non-degree ‘certifications’ from small unaffiliated organizations.

    6

    OUR RECOMMENDATIONS FOR GREAT DANES


    Science does show us that adding fresh foods to our Danes diet may help reduce the risk of bloat.

    An appropriate Great Dane kibble offers meat meals in the first ingredients and offers appropriate protein and calcium/phosphorus ratios for the life stage of the dog.

    Examples of fresh-food toppers that can be used for up to 10% of the total diet include:

    • Hydrated Dr. Harvey’s (one scoop)
    • Rehydrated Olewo Carrots (great for dogs that suffer from chronic loose stools)
    • Rehydrated Olewo Beets
    • Fresh fruits such as blueberries, bananas or apples
    • Fresh veggies such as carrots, zucchini, cauliflower and even lettuce (a head of lettuce makes a great enrichment activity! Dogs love to shred them)
    • Unsalted sardines packed in water or frozen/whole
    • Unsalted bone broth (make it at home!)

    The following foods for Great Danes are heavily researched, backed by legitimate nutrition science, and are fed to millions of robust, healthy dogs worldwide.

    For Puppies:

    Check out THE GIANT DOG FOOD PROJECT to compare brands and values.

    For Adults:

    How to choose a kibble for a Great Dane Dog

    When choosing a kibble, you should ideally choose a company that follows the guidelines recommended by the non-profit World Small Animal Veterinary Association (WSAVA) regarding manufacturer standards.

    These are nothing more than recommendations and the WSAVA does not ‘certify’, ‘approve’ or profit directly from the sale of brands that meet these standards. If you are unsure whether your kibble is meeting these guidelines, call the company and ask them directly to answer these questions without giving you the run-around:

    • The company should fully employ at least one dedicated nutritionist with a Ph.D in nutrition or a veterinarian boarded in nutrition (DACVN). If they simply consult with these professionals in lieu of employing them, they don’t likely have complete oversight of the formulation, formula changes or otherwise.
    • All formulas should be formulated by the above person; somebody who is truly qualified to create foods that are balanced not only nutritionally, but functionally as well. Being a general practice veterinarian, pet expert, dog lover or having a background working in ‘pet nutrition’ isn’t necessarily a qualification that meets this recommendation.
    • All diets should undergo extensive feeding trials and then meet or exceed AAFCO standards. Foods should exceed these standards both in formulation and following a rigorous analysis. Meeting these guidelines ‘on paper’ by formulation or anecdotal evidence only is not enough.
    • The company/manufacturer should own and operate their own facilities and laboratories and thus, maintain full oversight and control of the production process including control and diligent monitoring.
    • They should be transparent and open about their testing, process and recall history. (Note that recalls are a positive sign that a company is making ethical choices; not a sign of poor quality control. A company with no recalls is actually a red flag.)
    • The company should be involved in transparent and rigorous peer-reviewed and published testing and research. Ideally, this dedication to nutrition would not just be of their foods, but of canine nutrition in general. This is especially true if they make health claims or create unusual formulations that are outside of the industry standards. Claiming to have a ‘proprietary’ formula is a red flag.

    Having ‘no recalls’ is a RED FLAG
    If a company is relying on the ‘no recalls’ tactic for marketing purposes, they are unlikely to recall a food for minor reasons; reasons that could ultimately be devastating for a percentage of dogs fed that food.

    Recalls show that a company is diligent about avoiding mistakes and willing to hold itself accountable for problems with formulation or its supply chain. Be worried when a company says they have had ‘no recalls.

    Secondary (nutrition-related) DCM is not being seen in foods formulated by Purina, Hills, Royal Canin, Iams or Eukanuba.

    17 1

    JOIN THE FOLLOWING GROUPS ON FACEBOOK

    https://www.facebook.com/groups/CanineNutrition

    https://www.facebook.com/groups/TaurineDCM/

    ADDITIONAL DCM & GRAIN FREE RESOURCES AND INFORMATION

    https://www.docofalltrades.net/2020/12/diet-associated-non-hereditary-dcm-q.html?fbclid=IwAR14kE472FQwnU3_5Byek0nk1o6EXkbd7Lt5b0SrUrxEQ1bimY4t_bjp9ks

    https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/jvim.16397?fbclid=IwAR1XOoB-1hEISt3bqazqAR8K7MtHpCopr-gBdWjyXEv-7nCbWlzdtv6X25I

    https://www.fda.gov/animal-veterinary/outbreaks-and-advisories/fda-investigation-potential-link-between-certain-diets-and-canine-dilated-cardiomyopathy

    https://www.docofalltrades.net/2022/04/randomized-feeding-trial-in-labradors

    https://vetnutrition.tufts.edu/2016/06/why-you-shouldnt-judge-a-pet-food-by-its-ingredient-list

    READ MORE:

    Gentle Giants Dog Food Review

  • Life’s Abundance Dog Food Review for Great Danes

    Life’s Abundance Dog Food Review for Great Danes

    We occasionally like to pick a random pet food brand or gear and do a review. On the list, today is our Life’s Abundance Dog food review. This popular food is often recommended by breeders (who receive kickbacks for selling it), however, it is rarely if ever recommended by veterinarians. I wanted to dig into why that is!

    Many breeders will offer and promote Life’s Abundance puppy food to puppy buyers, and may even require it as part of your contract or health guarantee!

    This is not your typical review! We are not a dog food clickbait site – you won’t see us breaking down the merits of a food solely on its ingredients, but rather, it’s manufacturing process, formulation practices, and overall ethics.

    Let’s dig in!

    17

    Life’s Abundance Food & Great Dane Breeder Recommendations

    It is really important to understand first that Life’s Abundance Food is an MLM Marketing Scheme.

    That means that it’s often sold through a hierarchy of distributors (often breeders) who make a profit on the sale of the food. They can also profit by building teams through the recruitment of ‘Field Representatives’.

    Simply put, the promotion of Life’s Abundance dog food is done in a similar way to other MLM brands such as Herbalife, Scentsy, Mary Kay, and Young living Oils.

    Because their ability to profit from this product is directly tied to their ability to sell it to buyers and recruit other sellers, breeders are greatly motivated to produce more and more puppies to uphold their income stream.

    This may be done without regard to health, structure, or diligence to breed type.

    The Great Dane Breeders who are successful in selling lots of puppies will often be fanatic in their promotion of Life’s Abundance because, for them, it’s a winning numbers game.

    More puppies produced = more food sales.

    This creates an environment where unethical breeders are encouraged to breed more and more in the pursuit of ongoing commission-driven profits from puppy buyers.

    13

    Life’s Abundance is NOT a Dog Food Manufacturer or Company

    Life’s Abundance is an MLM that sells nutritional supplements, cleaning supplies, and randomly…dog food.

    Life’s Abundance is NOT a dog food company, and as of this writing, they do not manufacture or pack their products.

    Additionally, the company does not make AAFCO Nutritional or formulation information easy to find.

    As far as we can tell the brand is not involved in ongoing peer-reviewed nutritional research or legitimate testing. Despite this, their marketing relies heavily on the promotion that they sell a ‘proprietary’ blend of ingredients.

    Without extensive testing and feeding trials, there is no proof behind the ‘health’ claims that this brand makes.

    Life’s Abundance reps love to talk about how the brand is ‘free of recalls‘, however, this is intentionally misleading marketing. It can also be wildly unethical (see our study on Victor dog food, which had no recalls until November 2023 when it was discovered by a 3rd party that they had been selling contaminated food for months with no accountability).

    ‘No Recalls’ is a red flag.
    Recalls are a positive sign that a brand is making efforts to uphold standards and mitigate formulation and production issues within its product.

    A brand with no recalls, that wishes to uphold that record for marketing purposes is likely to ‘hide’ minor formulation and quality control problems instead of recalling them publicly.

    In other words, ‘no recalls’ is NOT a key indicator of quality and safety. Recalls can happen for several reasons and many are not catastrophic.

    12 1

    Life’s Abundance Dog Food and Breeder Ethics

    Many breeders who promote and profit from this product will offer a more robust health guarantee to buyers who keep their puppies on this food.

    Some will even require that the food and/or supplements be purchased, no matter what.

    The health guarantee and breeder support may become ‘void’ if the food’s auto shipment is turned off, and these breeders may even require that you return the puppy to them if you don’t support their food commission scheme.

    It is not uncommon for puppy buyers to feel pressured into keeping their puppies on Life’s Abundance foods and supplements despite knuckling, chronic loose stools, stomach problems, allergies, flat feet, heart problems or low energy.

    All of these are health problems where nutrition, especially nutrition from a company that has no legitimate scientific backing, may play a key role.

    It is extremely unethical for a breeder to require the purchase of Life’s Abundance food and/or supplements. We consider this practice a key red flag, as it often rides in tandem with other unethical breeding practices such as inadequate health testing and breeding dogs with questionable structure.

    8 3

    Life’s Abundance Quality

    Life’s Abundance makes it difficult to find their ingredients list; on their website, you can expect a list of ingredients within the food, but not in any particular order.

    We are not board-certified Veterinary Nutritionists, so we have no business commenting on the specific ingredients, formulation, or health claims.

    Coincidentally, neither do the breeders, ‘Dog Food Advisor’, or any other ‘food rating’ website.

    Not to mention the fact that Life’s Abundance is not even formulated by a credentialed, board-certified veterinary nutritionist (DACVN).

    A DACVN is one of the only people qualified to completely formulate kibble dog food and judge ingredients. (Read more here: https://vetnutrition.tufts.edu/2016/06/why-you-shouldnt-judge-a-pet-food-by-its-ingredient-list/)

    The person in charge of creating the Life’s Abundance recipes is a ‘holistic’ veterinarian whose writings and focus seem to have been on…cats. While some people may take no issue with this, consider this.

    The current FDA warnings about grain-free foods and boutique diets causing heart problems indicate that the problem is strongly correlated with boutique diets that are not formulated and rigorously tested by a credentialed veterinary nutritionist. So yes, that should alarm you.

    Life’s Abundance is a marketing company, not a pet nutrition expert company.

    The nutritional analysis of protein, calcium, and phosphorus in some Life’s Abundance formulas appear to be appropriate for Great Dane puppies, however, we are unable to definitively say if the correct balance of other nutrients (including key meat-based amino acids) is present.

    For a 40lb bag (the typical size needed when raising Great Danes), you can expect to pay nearly $100.

    As with all MLM products, the price is high to support the commission-based business model, not necessarily because it’s a higher-quality product.

    We do not recommend Life’s Abundance dog food and encourage you to tread cautiously with any breeder that is heavily promoting, selling or encouraging this brand.

    The same can be said for Life’s Abundance supplements and NuVet Vitamins, which we will cover in another blog post.

    Do you sell or use Lifes Abundance dog food? Leave your comments below! We are open to friendly, polite, scientific dialogue on this topic.

  • Does Resting After Meals Prevent Bloat in Dogs?

    Does Resting After Meals Prevent Bloat in Dogs?

    Bloat in Great Danes is a terrifying and deadly medical emergency.

    If you have a large or giant-breed dog, it is extremely important that you understand what bloat is and how to spot it before it becomes worse.

    Signs of bloat include: unsuccessful attempts to vomit, gagging, excess drooling, distress, distended abdomen and collapse.

    It is often said that to prevent bloat, you must require your dog to rest before and especially after meals. However, there is more to this story.

    Read on for more information on if resting after meals can prevent bloat.  

    DOES RESTING AFTER MEALS PREVENT BLOAT?

    Here is where things get tricky.

    There is actually NO scientific proof that resting does anything to prevent bloat. 

    As a matter of fact, that entire concept relies on assumptions…not science.

    One study by Tufts University actually found that there was no correlation at all between exercise and bloat. 

    (Read that study here: https://www.vin.com/apputil/content/defaultadv1.aspx?pId=11165&meta=Generic&id=3848657)

    Dogs may be just as likely to bloat when they are resting as when they are running!

    It is often reported that many dogs bloat in the middle of the night and on an empty stomach. As a matter of fact, this was true for most of the dogs that participated in the Tufts University study. They weren’t exercising when bloat happened; they were resting.  

    That fact should put a lot of doubt into the validity of ‘resting’ as a legitimate ‘preventative’. Just because as a theory it ‘makes sense’, doesn’t mean it’s going to prevent bloat. At all.

    Think about this.

    If resting after meals actually worked as a reliable preventative, the rate of bloat incidence would be going DOWN in Great Danes, not up.

    In the last 30 years, bloat incidence has increased by 1500%.

    YIKES..and no, I did not accidentally add a zero. You read 1500% correctly.

    HOW TO PREVENT BLOAT

    Great Dane owners really hate this discussion. Making dogs rest after meals feels like the right thing to do, and perhaps it is a totally fine thing to do (why take the risk, after all?).

    Where it becomes problematic is in the anxiety that it causes Great Dane owners.

    Because this is so widely promoted as a ‘preventative’, people get nervous when their dog has a meal. To temper this anxiety, they may strictly limit food intake to once per day.

    Tufts University Study: single large meals each day increase the risk of bloat.

    Science shows as that smaller, more frequent meals are better for Great Danes.

    However, if an owner offers 2-3 meals per day and requires rest for an hour before and after each, the dog may be given fewer opportunities for meaningful enrichment and exercise.

    Oh, and they may still bloat anyways.

    THE AWFUL TRUTH ABOUT BLOAT IN GREAT DANES

    Time and time again we see Great Dane owners lose their dogs to bloat. They say “I did everything right, how did this happen?”, or “my dog was resting, I don’t understand”. 

    Honestly, that’s the worst part.

    This is not to make Great Dane owners feel helpless! It’s meant to shed some light on a real problem that we have in this community where assumptions are being heavily promoted as preventatives.

    FACT: They still don’t actually know what  triggers bloat. Science so far can only show us what leads to higher and lower risk factors. 

    The side effect of this is 1000’s of heartbroken Great Dane owners who feel that they did something wrong, when they likely didn’t do anything wrong at all.

    SHOULD YOU REST A GREAT DANE TO PREVENT BLOAT?

    It’s honestly up to you. As above, there is nothing inherently wrong with it so long as you don’t take it too far.

    Great Danes benefit from daily enrichment, exercise and training. Too much ‘rest’ or crate time isn’t necessarily the answer; we believe that there are other more impactful ways to minimize bloat risk. You can click on the links below to learn more about bloat.

    Want to read about some common bloat myths? Click here!

    Need more information on bloat? Click here!

    Want to read the Tufts study that we reference often? Go HERE. 

    SCIENCE-BACKED WAYS TO MINIMIZE BLOAT RISK

    • Avoid foods with fat in the first four ingredients.
    • Use puzzle feeders to encourage slow eating.
    • If choosing elevated feeders, keep them on the lower side of things.
    • Add fresh food toppers and fiber to the diet. We like balanced raw food, Dr. Harvey’s and Olewo Carrots. Make sure the diet is balanced as a whole!
    • Do not encourage resource guarding by hovering, messing with food or taking food away. Prevent resource guarding by not making it a problem in the first place.
    • Feed multiple smaller meals, not one large meal.
    • Use modern positive reinforcement and humane, thoughtful balanced training methods, not aversive training (alpha rolls, hitting, intimidation, etc.) or alpha/dominance (debunked) that have been proven to lead to increased stress, aggression, fear and frustration.
    • Address anxiety, stress and aggression with a highly qualified humane trainer.
    • Address gut health issues by seeking veterinary care, adding probiotics and finding a diet that is appropriate for your dog.
    • Choose ethical breeders that are 1000% dedicated to the pedigree, health, structure & temperament, and prove it with papers, titles, activities and practices. Be part of the movement that no longer supports puppy mills, backyard breeders or ‘friendly backyard breeder’ unethical breeding practices.

    The information contained in this post is for informational purposes only. We do our best to present the most up-to-date research, however it is up to the reader to make decisions regarding the health and well-being of their dog. We make no claims here to prevent or treat bloat or any other condition related to Great Danes. Find a veterinarian with GIANT breed experience, and chat with them. 

     

    Some of the products we list on our website contain affiliate links. If you choose to make a purchase, we may receive a small commission for referring you. This commission does not affect the price of the product and is used to fund this website and our content. 

  • How Long Do Great Danes Live?

    How Long Do Great Danes Live?

    How long do Great Danes live?

    Our favorite breed of dog is known by many to have a shorter lifespan, but that doesn’t have to be a reality. What is the Great Dane lifespan and how can we extend our favorite dog’s life?

    image 16

    Great Danes live an average of about 8-10 years, but with good breeding practices and a proper diet and exercise regime, they can live up to 12 years old or more!

    Many people have experienced the devastating loss of a Great Dane at a young age and this happens most often because of bloat, heart conditions, orthopedic problems, and other genetic issues.

    On the flip side, many people have had Great Danes live for 10 years or even longer!

    There is a misperception about the lifespan of Great Danes, and we are here to fix that. Great Danes make amazing family pets in the right homes, and can absolutely live long and healthy lives.

    GREAT DANE LIFESPAN

    HOW LONG DO GREAT DANES LIVE?

    HOW LONG DO GREAT DANES LIVE

    It is well known that Great Danes tend to have shorter lives than other smaller dogs. This is because they are a giant breed and are prone to a number of health problems. (Health Risks in Great Danes)

    Great Danes live, on average, 8-10 years.

    Many smaller dogs live 10-15 years, for comparison.

    The average life expectancy of a gentle giant is low, but it doesn’t have to be!

    The oldest Great Dane currently known in 2021 is Maggie Mae, at the ripe old age of 16.

    Some of the health problems that Great Danes are prone to include canine hip dysplasia and elbow dysplasia, bloat, cancer, and heart disease which can lower the average life span. All of these health issues can be genetic, and lead to a shorter lifespan in the breed as a whole.

    BLOATLEARN ABOUT BLOAT HERE
    IS BLOAT PREVENTABLE?
    GASTROPEXY SURGERY- STOMACH TACKING
    DOES GUT HEALTH RELATE TO BLOAT?
    HOW FAST DOES BLOAT HAPPEN?
    JOINT AND BONE DISEASESArthritis in Great Danes
    Laser Therapy for Joint Pain
    How to Help a Dog with a Broken Leg
    Using CBD for My Dog’s Pain
    Canine Hip and Elbow Dysplasia

    Great Danes can live long, robust lives. While 8-10 years is the average, many live to be 12 years of age or more!

    Since Great Danes are such big dogs, they frequently suffer from a list of health issues that are often FATAL and nearly always GENETIC. These health issues significantly lower the average expected lifespan. Unethical breeding practices are to blame, not the Great Dane breed itself.

    What is OFA Health Testing?
    Is Embark a ‘Good Enough’ Health Test?
    Health Risks in Great Danes

    It is entirely possible to keep a Great Dane healthy- and it all starts with choosing an ethical breeder for your Dane puppy.

    Bad Breeders
    Scam Breeders: What to Look For
    Breeders: Shady Business
    Should I Choose a Breeder or Rescue?

    Find a Great Dane Rescue
    Choosing a Dog From a Show Breeder

    HOW LONG DO GREAT DANES LIVE

    A harlequin Great Dane in the grass. A Great Dane’s life expectancy does not need to be short! Big dogs can live a long and healthy, happy life.

    The health conditions that can impact a Great Dane and other big dog breeds include: 

    • Wobblers Disease (Genetic link) (Wobblers)
    • Arthritis (Genetic link, especially when looking at structural problems that contribute) (Arthritis in Great Danes)
    • Cancer (Genetic link)
    • Bloat (Genetic link) (What is Bloat?)
    • Blood Clotting Disorders (Genetic)
    • Degenerative Disorders (Genetic link)
    • Heart Disease, including DCM (Genetic link)

    HEART DISEASE AND AVERAGE LIFE EXPECTANCY OF A DOG’S LIFE

    DCM (Dilated Cardiomyopathy) is a silent killer. Many Danes are lost to this but it’s not always diagnosed; they often have very few symptoms and may pass suddenly (as if they had a heart attack).

    Heart Disease and Other Health Conditions
    Is My Dog ‘Filling Out’ or Getting Fat?
    8 Nutrition Facts to Keep Your Dog at the Right Weight
    Obesity in Great Danes: Fat Danes Face Serious Health Risks

    BLOAT IN GIANT BREED DOGS

    Bloat is an exceptionally dangerous and scary killer; it happens fast and can take a Great Dane’s life in a matter of hours.

    LEARN ABOUT BLOAT HERE
    IS BLOAT PREVENTABLE?
    GASTROPEXY SURGERY- STOMACH TACKING
    DOES GUT HEALTH RELATE TO BLOAT?
    HOW FAST DOES BLOAT HAPPEN?

    BLOOD CLOTTING DISORDERS AND HUGE DOGS

    Blood clotting disorders are often to blame for Great Danes that don’t make it through routine surgical procedures such as spaying and neutering.

    WOBBLERS SYNDROME AND LARGE DOGS

    Wobblers is a devastating disease that takes mobility away from Great Danes.

    Wobblers Syndrome and Pain Relief

    BONE DISEASE AND GIANT BREEDS

    A Great Dane’s life span is highly impacted by the dog’s quality of joints and mobility.

    Hip Dysplasia is a chronic disease that impacts Great Danes and other large dog breeds.

    Arthritis in Great Danes
    Laser Therapy for Joint Pain
    How to Help a Dog with a Broken Leg
    Using CBD for My Dog’s Pain
    Canine Hip Dysplasia

    Your dog’s chances of developing Hip and Elbow Dysplasia are higher if you choose a reputable breeder who’s dogs have a health history of having Hip Dysplasia or other joint related health problems.

    How to Find a Great Dane Breeder Near Me
    What is OFA Health Testing?
    What Makes a Breeder Good?

    JOINT SUPPLEMENTS FOR GENTLE GIANTS

    Since Great Danes frequently suffer from joint problems, and it is known that mobility issues can lower the average lifespan, it is important to start your Great Danes on joint supplements. Great Danes should be on a joint supplement from the time they are just a Great Dane puppy until they are adult dogs.

    When you are raising Great Dane puppies, keep them on a healthy diet and Buffered Esther Vitamin C, which will support their joints and keep them from knuckling.

    Is My Great Dane Puppy Knuckling?
    Puppy Food for Great Danes
    How to Prevent Knuckling in Great Dane Puppies
    Is My Great Dane Puppy Too Small?
    Great Dane Puppy Growth Chart
    How to Fix Knuckling in Great Danes

    image 100

    To support your dog’s joints during their adult lives, include Glucosamine and/or Dasuquin in their healthy diet to promote good health of their joints.

    81T6 1rbZFL. AC SL1500

    It is very unlikely that a Great Dane with any of these unfortunately common disorders will live long and robust (10+ year) lives.

    HOW DO I MAKE MY GREAT DANE LIVE LONGER?

    The reality here is that most of us want our Great Danes to live forever. So then, how do we make the Great Dane lifespan as long as possible and minimize the health risks?

    great dane ap 0pd23x 645

    There are things you can do to help them live long, healthy lives and increase the average lifespan. The most important one starts with the breeder you choose. 

    HOW DOES BACKYARD BREEDING IMPACT THE WAY A GREAT DANE LOOKS?
    HOW DOES SPAYING A GREAT DANE TOO YOUNG IMPACT A WAY A GREAT DANE LOOKS?
    The Great Dane Breed Standard

    CHOOSE A RESPONSIBLE BREEDER

    Many of the Great Dane breeders perpetuating these common health problems are friendly, say they ‘health test’, breed often and have cute puppies and nice websites!

    Treat cautiously with ‘friendly backyard breeders’ who are more interested in profits than the breed itself.

    Breeders: Shady Business
    Should I Choose a Breeder or Rescue?
    Choosing a Dog From a Show Breeder
    What Makes a Breeder Good?
    What is a backyard breeder? The AKC has 1000’s.

    Friendly backyard breeders may even be popular, especially on social media. It’s easy to fall into this trap, and it’s unfortunate because bad genetics is like a game of telephone. 

    It’s very hard to get rid of the bad genetics so long as they continue to be reproduced.

    CHOOSE A GENTLE GIANT THAT HAS BEEN HEALTH TESTED

    What is OFA Health Testing
    Is Embark a ‘Good Enough’ Health Test?

    Wobblers, bloat, heart issues, blood clotting disorders, anxiety, painful structural problems (including flat feet and roached back) and even cancer have genetic links that can be traced back to the lineage and careless breeding.

    HOW TO TRIM YOUR PUPPIES NAILS
    HOW TO STRENGTHEN YOUR DOG’S FEET

    TAKE CARE OF YOUR GREAT DANE

    great dane dogs puppies 5

    Great Danes require different care than other dogs or other breeds.

    Knowing what type of care your Great Danes require can help to increase their life span.

    You can help extend the life of your Great Dane, and improve the lives of the breed as a whole by taking the following steps:

    KEEPING YOUR GREAT DANES LEAN AND NOT OVERWEIGHT

    Since Great Danes are the largest dogs, Great Dane owners are often found ‘fighting’ over whose dog is bigger.

    This is completely backwards and will lead to a shorter life span!

    Some Great Danes are bigger naturally and will still lead a healthy life.

    However, so many Great Danes are overweight and obese, which in turn, leads to short life spans.

    Take your Great Danes swimming, provide them with activity and a healthy diet. Only a handful of Great Danes are ACTUALLY too thin!

    Socialization Activities For Great Danes
    Can Great Danes Swim?
    Is My Puppy Too Skinny?

    Their waistline should be visible when looking down at your dog from above, and you should be able to feel their ribs with light pressure but not see them.

    130479238 3909610185724275 1078472556990510126 n
    An Underweight Great Dane
    34
    A Healthy Weight Great Dane
    33
    An Overweight Great Dane

    An hour a day of moderate activity is what’s recommended for most adult Great Danes.

    Is My Dog ‘Filling Out’ or Getting Fat?
    8 Nutrition Facts to Keep Your Dog at the Right Weight
    Obesity in Great Danes: Fat Danes Face Serious Health Risks

    DECREASE RISK OF BLOAT

    Bloat is one of the largest killers of Great Danes and leads to a short life span in the breed altogether.

    Working to prevent bloat in the first place will help your dog lead a longer life span. (Read more)

    What is Bloat?
    Can You Prevent Bloat?
    Stomach Tacking: Pros and Cons
    Bloat and Gut Health
    The Scary Bloat Timeline

    Bloat has several indicators of causation: gut health, anxiety, and genetics.

    There are a few theories that are just completely wrong in regards to bloat, and the myths perpetuate the communities:

    1. MYTH 1: Raised feeders can prevent bloat. WRONG!
    2. MYTH 2: Resting before and after a meal will prevent bloat. WRONG!
    3. MYTH 3: Large meals that are scheduled will prevent bloat. WRONG!

    READ MORE BLOAT MYTHS AND WHAT THE TRUTH ACTUALLY IS HERE!

    ELIMINATE ANXIETY

    Did you know that anxiety can actually shorten a Great Dane’s life? (More about lifespan here)

    Since ANXIETY, of all things, is a key indicator of bloat, it is absolutely crucial to keep your Great Dane stress free. (BLOAT AND ANXIETY)

    Use crate training as a form of keeping your dog stress-free and safe.

    How to Crate Train a Great Dane Puppy
    Crate Training: The Best Crates for Great Danes

    Use e collar training to help your Great Dane know the boundaries and rules of society, which will help your Great Dane lead a stress and anxiety free life.

    KEEP THE NAILS TRIMMED AND SHORT ON YOUR GREAT DANE

    Since a big Great Dane is prone to developing painful arthritis, Great Danes need their nails kept trimmed and short.

    Check them regularly and if they get too long, it is far past due.

    THE BEST NAIL CLIPPERS AND FILERS FOR BIG DOGS
    GREAT DANE NAIL TOOLS
    HOW TO TRIM YOUR PUPPIES NAILS
    HOW TO STRENGTHEN YOUR DOG’S FEET
    THE 7 BEST NAIL CLIPPERS FOR GREAT DANES

    If you have a Great Dane, you should be familiar with the tools required to groom their nails, and become familiar with how to use them.

    Your options are to use a Dremel or nail clippers.

    Click below to shop our favorites of each.

    ee5825f2 aa18 4d31 b54e 6bba5994a686
    a1716fa2 3e48 4aed bfae 443b47089353

    A Great Dane should get their nails trimmed weekly! If you are not comfortable trimming the nails of your Great Dane by yourself, you should schedule regular veterinary visits to get them taken care of.

    A Great Dane has big, strong nails, so it can be very painful if they are touching the floor.

    More so, it can actually cause joint and structural issues if the nails of a Great Dane are too long.

    Check out our favorite grooming tools for the big nails of a Great Dane here.

    EXERCISE FOR A GREAT DANE

    Great Danes are NOT couch potatoes!

    Nothing in life, not a Great Dane and not smaller breeds should be left stagnant!

    Most dogs thrive when they get an abundance of free play, exercise, and training, which can help them grow both physically and mentally.

    Puppy Culture: A Way to Socialize from the Start
    Puppy Socialization Guide
    Puppy Training: 5 Mistakes in Training
    Canine Good Citizen Training for Great Danes
    Your Puppy is Bored

    Proper exercise for a Great Dane includes offering plenty of free play and exploration on soft, varied terrain. For this reason, we believe that all Great Danes should be reliably off-leash trained!

    Using an e collar to train your Great Dane is one of the best ways to ensure that you can provide your Great Dane with the proper amount of free play and freedom that they need.

    E Collar Training Guide
    E Collar Myths
    What is an E Collar?
    SHOULD I USE A BARK COLLAR ON MY GREAT DANE?
    What is the Difference Between an E Collar and a Shock Collar?
    9 Reasons to E Collar Train Your Great Dane Puppy
    Is the Gentle Leader an Abusive Tool?
    99 Reasons Why to Use an E Collar and a Shock Ain’t One
    Things that are More Aversive Than an E Collar in Training
    E Collars are NOT Shock Collars
    Proper E Collar Placement
    E Collar Comfort Pads

    THE SINGLE MOST IMPORTANT THING

    If we want to increase the lifespan of Great Danes, choosing responsible breeders is the most important, humane and thoughtful thing any of us can do.

    animals dogs dutch green grass

    Good breeders are actively looking reduce the incidence of bloat, cardiomyopathy, wobblers and cancer.

    People need to understand that poor breeding practices are largely to blame, not the breed itself.

    READ MORE:

    Great Dane Not Eating – What to Do

    Great Dane Farts: The Funniest Collection of Photos and Videos on the Internet

    The Best Collars for Great Danes

    Blue Great Danes – Facts, Photos, and Care

    The Top 5 Adorable Facts About Great Dane Brindle Dogs

    Want more information on Great Danes? Read the resources at the Great Dane Club of America. and the Great Dane Club of Canada.

  • Should I Use a Bark Collar on My Great Dane?

    Should I Use a Bark Collar on My Great Dane?

    Should I Use a Bark Collar on My Great Dane?

    If you are asking whether or not to use a bark collar on your Great Dane, we’re taking a wild guess that you are pretty fed up with the racket.

    Right?

    Great Danes have HUGE barks and it can be annoying, intimidating and frustrating (especially to your neighbors!).

    Should you use a bark collar for your Great Dane, or are there better ways? Read on, friends…

    Should I Use a Bark Collar on My Great Dane?

    Bark collars work by adding something aversive (bad or uncomfortable) when your dog barks.

    For example, a shock correction, https://www.hellodanes.com/should-i-use-a-bark-collar-on-my-great-dane/an ultrasonic noise, a beep or a spritz of citronella.

    In theory, your dog learns that barking = punishment.

    Unlike E-Collars and Shock Collars, bark collars are automated. They don’t require you to do anything; if the dog barks, the collar will correct your dog.

    Should I Use a Bark Collar on My Great Dane

    THERE ARE FOUR PRIMARY REASONS THAT DOGS BARK:

    Habit
    Boredom
    Anxiety
    Breed Trait

    WHY DO DOGS BARK?

    Before you work on training your dog not to bark, you MUST figure out why the barking is happening in the first place. Keep in mind that barking is a natural, normal thing, not unlike how humans talk to express frustration, relieve boredom and communicate.

    Look at the following situations and see if any apply to your dog:

    1. Habit – Your dog knows the mailman comes everyday at 3pm and waits to bark. The behavior has been unchecked and practiced daily.
    2. Boredom – Your dog barks at the window all day long, barks to hear himself talk and/or may bark to demand things. This goes hand-in-hand with habit.
    3. Anxiety – Your dog is stressed out by other dogs in the neighbor yard, stressed out when you leave the house, stressed out by people visiting your home, stressed on a leash and/or stressed out by noises in the environment.
    4. Breed Trait – Remember, by nature Great Danes do seek to ‘protect’ and alert. Many times, barking is just that. It’s important for that trait not to become obsession, or for it to be based primarily in fear and anxiety (which is VERY different than true alert barking).

    Many dogs bark for ALL of these reasons!

    SHOULD I USE A BARK COLLAR?

    Ok so you’ve evaluated that your dog is bored, anxious and/or has developed bad habits.

    Before you even think about a bark collar, you MUST address the root causes. 

    HABIT

    Should I Use a Bark Collar on My Great Dane

    HABIT: Find ways to change the routine. Don’t allow the behavior to be practiced in the first place. Change your daily habits so that your dog can, too.

    BOREDOM

    Should I Use a Bark Collar on My Great Dane

    BOREDOM: Add mental and physical enrichment, LOTS of it! Take a training class. Go for a hike. Off-leash train. Work on Canine Good Citizen skills. Play search and scent games. Clicker train. (Toys, a yard and another dog to play with are rarely enough!)

    ANXIETY

    Should I Use a Bark Collar on My Great Dane

    ANXIETY: A dog that is stressed out by the environment and by separation is a dog that needs your help. Work with a trainer to lower anxiety (and ultimately, lower the risk of bloat!), address separation anxiety and teach your dog that the world is an ok place.

    BREED TRAIT

    Should I Use a Bark Collar on My Great Dane

    BREED TRAIT: Some breeds are DESIGNED to bark! They may be EXTREMELY bored without a job to do.

    MY DOG IS BORED!

    UNDERSTANDING WHY YOUR DOG BARKS

    It’s important to understand that if you add a bark collar to a dog without addressing the root cause of the barking, there is a huge chance that you will confuse your dog or worse, increase their level of anxiety and stress. 

    Instead of relying on a hands-off tool, we much prefer to FIRST utilize training, mental enrichment, boundaries, routine and structure.

    THEN, if you have put the time into properly conditioning your dog to a legitimate E-Collar, you can use it to deter a barking habit in a hands-on, positive way.

    Basically put…do not put an automated bark collar on your unsuspecting, bored, stressed out, untrained dog and expect miracles. Address the root cause first, then look again at your options.

    Why is Leash Training so Hard?
    5 Leash Training Tips
    Puppy Training: 5 Mistakes in Training
    What is Balanced Training?
    Respect Training Tips: How to Train Your Puppy Great Dane
    Is My Great Dane Being Aggressive?
    Canine Good Citizen Training for Great Danes

    A quality bark collar may be an appropriate choice is when all underlying issues have been addressed and the dog is in a home where being surrendered, euthanized or picked up by animal control may be a reality otherwise.

    Should I Use a Bark Collar on My Great Dane

    We support the humane, ethical use of high-quality stimulation collars for communication and training. 

    A E-Collar from E-Collar Technologies may help resolve barking in dogs where root cause has been fully addressed AND the dog has been conditioned to the collar. A collar like this can also be used for recall and more. This is a hands-on approach. The truth is that you may find a massive reduction in barking, without corrections, just by jumping solidly into a new training and enrichment routine. 

    You can learn more about E-Collar training HERE: E Collar Guide

    Shop E-Collar Technologies HERE:

    218102006 159973869533988 2344798461813887346 n

    The collar you choose to buy REALLY matters. Click to see the devices we vouch for.

    For a hands-off approach, the ONLY bark collars that we recommend for the LAST DITCH EFFORT type situation is the E-Collar Technologies Barkless Pro E-Collar or the Garmin Pro BarkLimiter. These use a more humane E-Collar tech stimulation (not shock) and advanced technology when correcting the dog, which is the most appropriate choice IF you are going to use a bark collar.

    Day Pouch Treat Bag Review
    Is the Gentle Leader an Abusive Tool?
    Prong Collar Review

    Unlike the versatile E-collars above, automated bark control is the only thing these tools do.

    READ MORE:
    The Best Collars for Great Danes
    How to Crate Train a Great Dane Puppy
    E Collar Myths
    What is an E Collar?
    What is the Difference Between an E Collar and a Shock Collar?
    9 Reasons to E Collar Train Your Great Dane Puppy

  • 5 Tips for Leash Training Great Danes

    5 Tips for Leash Training Great Danes

    Leash training Great Danes is a challenge but SO important.

    Teaching your Great Dane to walk politely on a leash is an important skill that can reduce your risk of injury, and theirs too!

    Leash Training Great Danes

    Does your Great Dane pull a lot, choke themselves on their leash and embarrass you in public?

    You’ve come to the right place! Here are our top 5 tips for leash training your Great Dane!

    Leash Training Great Danes

    1. CHOOSE THE RIGHT GEAR

    When leash training your Great Dane, we recommend starting with a flat buckle or martingale collar and a quality leash. (More info on no-pull tools is offered later in the blog!).

    Day Pouch Treat Bag Review
    Is the Gentle Leader an Abusive Tool?
    Things that are More Aversive Than an E Collar in Training
    Dog Halo Collar Review
    The Best Leashes for Great Danes

    Martingale collars are escape proof and a great choice for dogs that easily back out of collars. (You can purchase beautiful, handmade martingale collars from Magnolia Mutts. She donates profits to Great Dane rescues).

    The Best Collars for Great Danes

    Or choose a 1.5-2.0″ wide collar, some of our favorites are below.

    2. USE HIGH VALUE TREATS & LOTS OF PRAISE

    One big reason so many people struggle with walking their Great Dane on a leash is that they haven’t put enough time yet into teaching the dog the correct behavior.

    Positive reinforcement is the best way to teach the dog what you want: in this case, walking by your side!

    You can practice rewarding your dog after just one step, then two, then five and so on until you are confidently walking down the block. Keep the leash loose in your hands and encourage your dog to interact with you! Don’t worry, like any training tool, the goal here is to completely fade out the use of the treats. Take it easy and gradually replace treats with praise over time. 

    Need a place to carry the treats? We LOVE this training bag on Amazon.

    ]

    3. START IN A LOW DISTRACTION AREA

    You can give your dog all the treats in the world, but it WILL NOT work if you are trying to train your dog when they are already distracted and pulling.

    Why is Leash Training so Hard?
    5 Leash Training Tips
    Puppy Training: 5 Mistakes in Training

    You must start your leash skills training indoors where the environment is predictable and boring.

    Kind of like Kindergarten! Work at your dogs level and only approach college level requirements when your dog is actually ready for it. Thoroughly teach the ‘HEEL’ or ‘WITH ME’ commands so you can work your way up to doing those skills in a more distracting area. Set up an obstacle course in your house and practice loose leash walking around it!

    4. KEEP PRACTICING

    Work on your leash training skills for a few minutes each, several times per day both off-leash and on in your living room and fenced yard if you have one.

    Leash Training Great Danes

    As your dog is better able to keep the leash loose and focus on you, offer lots of praise and work on this skill in a new (but still easy) area such as Home Depot (on a quiet day) or a quiet park. Remember, you can train your dog to ‘HEEL’ the same way you train any other trick. It’s just a game!

    Make sure to allow your dog PLENTY of time to also sniff about and explore. This calm enrichment teaches them to be comfortable in the environment. Stay positive and aware of your surroundings AND your own behavior. Tension from you = tension from your dog. 

    5. LEARN ABOUT TRAINING TOOLS FOR GREAT DANES

    Many people are curious about the best leash training tools for Great Danes. Here is our quick rundown on tools that can be used, but that must ALSO be paired with proper training mentioned above.

    HEAD COLLAR

    Head Collar: This popular tool relies on pressure to your dog’s face, making it very uncomfortable for the dog to pull. Many dogs find it to be aversive to wear and will paw at it, whine or even shut down. This option, if used, should be paired with diligent conditioning and training to prevent pulling in the first place, as a dog that lunges in a head collar can injure himself.

    Head collars should never be used on dogs with entropion, cherry eye, poor structure (including incorrect head/neck/front assembly) or Wobblers. Contrary to popular belief, the ‘head collar’ or ‘gentle leader’ is not actually positive or gentle, and we believe that for most owners, this tool is not actually the best choice.

    GENTLE LEADER REVIEW

    PRONG COLLAR

    Prong Collar: This collar distributes pressure evenly around the dog’s neck. When used properly, a prong collar will not pop a balloon, and when applied to your arm will simply feel like pressure that goes away as soon as you release the tension.

    They look scary but that doesn’t mean that they are. Prong collars are not aversive to wear, and with a few quick, positive conditioning exercises they become a cue to your dog to redirect and look at you for direction. The pressure, if needed, is safer and better for your dog than the pressure that they get when they pull wildly into a flat collar or harness.

    When fit and used correctly, prong collars are a surprisingly gentle option, as they don’t rely on restrictions to movement or force. Many canine chiropractors advocate for prongs paired with positive reinforcement as the tool of choice, for a reason. We recommend working with a trainer, however. Jerking your dog around or purely relying on a prong collar to do the job is NOT how this tool works. Herm Sprenger brand is the only good choice.

    NO PULL HARNESS

    No-Pull Harness: No pull and front-clip harnesses rely on the same concept as prong collars and head collars; applying pressure that makes it uncomfortable to pull and rewarding to stop. No Pull Harnesses also alter the way a dog moves, may throw them off balance and will nearly always restrict the movement of the shoulders. We do not recommend the use of front clip harnesses such as ‘Easy Walk’ or ‘Petsafe’, and contrary to popular belief they are not a positive or dog-friendly option. The exception to harnesses may be an athletic fit y-front harness (shown below) with a front-clip, if necessary, and transition to back clip use.

    CHAIN COLLAR

    Chain Collar: Chain collars look cool, but they should not be used as a ‘necklace’. Trainers use them as an audible correction; they are not meant to choke the dog. The ‘zip’ of the chain sliding through the ring is enough to get most dogs attention, but it will not work if the dog is already pulling into the collar. We believe there are better choices, however for this option we recommend a martingale style chain (see below).

    71LMpx4TJYL. AC SL1500
    Ruffwear Chain Reaction – See it here on Amazon

    E COLLAR

    E-Collar – the modern high-quality E-Collar, when used properly, is more humane and less aversive than any other training tool (including no-pull harness and head collar) listed above. They CAN be used for leash skills, too, but you have to do it right. Read more in our E-Collar training guide here: https://www.hellodanes.com/product/great-dane-e-collar-training-guide/

    E Collar Training Guide
    E Collar Myths
    What is an E Collar?
    What is the Difference Between an E Collar and a Shock Collar?

    ALL tools can be used incorrectly and result in pain, fear and downright abuse. It’s up to you to learn about each tool before using it on your dog. Tread cautiously with marketing that is meant to make you believe that ‘nylon’ tools are positive and metal tools are abusive and punishing! It’s not that simple. 

    The information contained in this post is for informational purposes only. We do our best to present the most up-to-date research, however it is up to the reader to make decisions regarding the health and well-being of their dog. We make no claims here to prevent or treat bloat or any other condition related to Great Danes. Find a veterinarian with GIANT breed experience, and chat with them. 

    Some of the products we list on our website contain affiliate links. If you choose to make a purchase, we may receive a small commission for referring you. This commission does not affect the price of the product and is used to fund this website and our content. 

  • What Does Euro Mean in Great Danes?

    What Does Euro Mean in Great Danes?

    If you are looking for a Great Dane puppy, or are just interested in the breed, you may be curious about a lot of things. A very common question that we get is “What does Euro mean in Great Danes?”

    There are actually a lot of misunderstandings about ‘Euro’ vs. ‘American’ Danes, and we’re going to clear that up. Fair warning, we like science and the written standard.

    7

    What Does Euro Mean in Great Danes?

    There are many Great Dane breeders in the U.S. who breed ‘Euro’ Great Danes. Occasionally they come from European lineage, however, more often they are simply dogs who have the ‘Euro’ look.

    In other words, being ‘Euro’ and ‘European’ is not necessarily the same thing.

    Common features of the ‘Euro’ type Great Dane include:

    • Shorter, bulkier, and stockier structure
    • Heavier weight
    • Slower movement, less athletic
    • Larger, more dome-shaped or apple-shaped head
    • Bigger jowls
    • Heavy ears that may be long and set low on the head
    • Larger feet
    • Mastiff-like features
    • Wide-set eyes that are often droopy and may have red haw showing

    Euro is a look, produced by breeders who intentionally breed for these traits.
    Many of these traits, especially those related to heft, movement, eyes, ears, jowls, and head shape are considered faults in the written standards for Great Danes.

    No matter what you think about the different, heftier look of ‘Euro’ Great Danes, it’s important to note that many FCI European Great Dane breeders are actually pretty frustrated that so many people think all European Danes are droopy and heavy. Interested in more information about ‘EURO’ Dane breeders? Read here.

    This ‘Euro’ Great Dane below is suffering from poor structure related to breeding for size, heft, and the ‘Euro’ look.

    30

    Euro vs. American Great Danes

    Every purebred dog has a written standard. The idea that there is a huge difference between American and European Great Danes is a myth.

    The U.S. follows the standard written by the Great Dane Club of America, while Europe uses the standard written by the FCI.

    According to these standards, a Great Dane from Europe should look very much the same as a Great Dane from the U.S., as both standards are nearly identical on paper. A Great Dane is a Great Dane.

    Below is a well-bred European Great Dane (used with permission).

    Screen Shot 2021 05 11 at 10.25.22 AM

    Well-bred dogs have good structure, health and type (they look like the breed standard)

    Just as ‘Euro’ might imply that a dog is heavier and drooper, many use the word ‘American’ to imply that a dog is lighter and more ‘greyhound’ like.

    Neither the ‘Euro’ nor the ‘American’ type dog meets the gold standard or goals for the breed as a whole.

    To compare, here is a well-bred Great Dane from the U.S., bred with the standard in mind. He is neither too refined, nor is he droopy and heavy. He is still a large, well-built dog.

    Bruce and the European-bred dog above are nearly the same.

    118187842 784623988953720 6269256817148332442 n

    What does Ethical Great Dane Breeding Look Like?

    In many ways, the deliberate pursuit of some exaggerated ‘Euro’ traits is unethical and problematic.

    Great Danes are already huge dogs and should not be intentionally bred for larger and stockier frames, droopier eyes, and larger jowls, especially if structural health, eye health, heart health, and longevity are casually ignored as a result.

    If you are looking for a Great Dane breeder, Euro or not, verify the following: 

    It’s ok to prefer a Great Dane with larger stature. Unethical backyard breeding practices, however, have led many to believe that all ‘American’ Danes are ‘refined’, which is just as unfortunate as the practice of intentionally breeding for size and droop, regardless of health.

    To put it simply, the word ‘EURO’ is a term associated largely with ‘friendly backyard breeding’ . Many of those breeders are more focused on size, heft, and profits than they are on robust health and breed standards.

    Use the slider below to toggle between a poorly bred EURO (hyper type) and a poorly bred AMERICAN (hypo type) Great Dane. Neither of these dogs meets the breed standard.

    812
    What does EURO mean in great danes 1

    For comparison, below are some very well-bred Great Danes that could fit any proper written standard (GDCA/U.S., GDCC/Canada, FCI/Europe).

    (Most of these photos are credited to Tina.)

    Screen Shot 2022 03 30 at 2.11.34 PM

    JOIN OUR COMMUNITY

    Do you like modern positive+balanced off-leash dog training, science-based information, life with Danes, educated ownership and chatting with other like-minded people?

    Join our growing Facebook group!

  • How to Prevent Knuckling in Great Danes in 6 Easy Steps

    How to Prevent Knuckling in Great Danes in 6 Easy Steps

    Knuckling in Great Danes is a serious issue, but one that is very treatable! Today we’re talking about how to prevent knuckling in Great Danes.

    While catching it early is important, ideally you want to prevent knuckling in the first place! 

    Before we get started, you may also be interested in information about whether or not your Great Dane is knuckling and how to treat it.

    Read on for our tips for preventing knuckling in Great Danes! 

    This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 11-2-1024x744.jpg

    HOW TO PREVENT KNUCKLING IN GREAT DANES

    1. Avoid hard and slick surfaces.

    This includes wood, tile, and yes, concrete! Puppies need soft places to rest their joints, walk, and exercise. Do not allow your puppy to slide around on floors or jump off furniture. Healthy play on soft, varied terrain is appropriate and will help strengthen joints!

    Put down lots of area rugs to keep joints safe and cushioned. We love washable rugs from Ruggable; they are perfect for homes with puppies, look beautiful, and offer just enough softness and traction.

    2. Strengthen Toes and Feet

    Strong feet are important to ensure that your puppy has a solid foundation to grow on. Walk and play on soft surfaces such as bedding, gym mats, sand, gravel, dirt, and grass.

    15 1

    By allowing your puppy to play on a variety of terrain, you are building muscles and strength that will help their feet grow correctly.

    3. Trim Your Dog’s Nails

    Keep nails short with weekly maintenance, starting as soon as your puppy is home with you! We love Millers Forge Red Handle clippers for tiny puppy nails, and we are introducing a rotary tool ASAP for when they are bigger.

    7 Best Dog Nail Clippers: Great Dane Toenail Problems

    4. Feed an Appropriate Diet

    Choose a large or giant breed puppy formula with meat and meat meals in the first ingredients, calcium at or below 1.2%, and phosphorus close behind. The food must also contain the AAFCO large breed growth statement.

    Do NOT mix kibble brands. Choose one and stick with it. The following foods meet the criteria:

    Check out THE GIANT DOG FOOD PROJECT to compare brands and values.

    5. Watch the Treats

    Do not let supplements, toppers, or treats make up more than 10% of the intake. Excess nutrition is harmful for Dane pups!

    6. Minimize Crate Time

    Crates are important for training, however, Great Dane puppies need the freedom to move naturally to develop joints, tendons, and bones. Limit crate time, especially if your puppy is in a crate overnight.

    Great Dane puppy joints are fragile and need to be cared for.

    With proper care, knuckling over is preventable and treatable. Without care, knuckled limbs may become painful and permanently deformed.

    All these things we listed work together to help prevent and treat knuckling in Great Dane puppies. Protect the joints, strengthen the joints, and lastly, provide the correct nutrition.

  • Halo Dog Collar Review (Our Honest take)

    Halo Dog Collar Review (Our Honest take)

    Today we are giving you our detailed, unpaid Halo Dog Collar review! The Halo Collar is a dog training collar that in theory, allows your dog to be off-leash anywhere you go. If you’ve found this popular post on our site, awesome! That means you are a dedicated pet owner looking to safely and humanely get your pup off-leash. We love that!

    People are interested in the Halo Dog training collar (and now the Halo 3 for dogs) because it offers something no other device has yet: automated boundaries for your dog using a phone app. Allow me to clarify:

    The idea is amazing. Put this Halo Collar on your dog, draw a boundary on a map in the phone app, and the collar will keep your dog inside of the boundary (with some training, of course!).

    Imagine the possibilities! This is an idea that many people have asked about but no company had done gracefully yet. Many other similar boundary collars and invisible fences for dogs are clunky, huge, and unreliable. Underground boundary fences can be hard to install (not to mention expensive!). Worse, many other off-leash training fences utilize painful shocks that cause dogs to scream and fear being in the yard.

    The Halo Dog Collars are marketed as a modern, more humane, and more effective alternative to traditional invisible shock fences.

    The difference between a Halo 3 collar and an invisible fence is huge.

    We were DEFINITELY intrigued and know that a lot of Great Dane owners are asking about Halo, Halo 2+, and Halo 3 Collar reviews.

    This is our review of the HALO dog Collar by Cesar Milan. Is this a Halo Collar buyer beware, or a Halo Collar buyer buy it? Read on, friends…

    Screen Shot 2023 10 24 at 11.34.19 AM 1

    Does the Halo 3 Dog Collar Shock the Dog?

    The Halo Dog Collar uses tone, voice corrections, and stimulation.

    Stimulation is an electrical current that causes the muscle to twitch. Think of this like a tactile sensation, no different than leash tension or touch. When used at low levels, muscle stimulation can be used as a positive tactile communication. This sensation is not the same as ‘shock’ and should not cause negative associations or feelings for dogs that are trained properly to understand what it means.

    On the other hand, when used at high levels, muscle stimulation is an aversive sensation that can be used as a correction. However, at low levels, it is an incredible tool that replaces leash tension.

    Think of it this way:

    Shock = sharp poke with a stick
    Low level stimulation = gentle leash pressure
    High level stimulation = stronger leash pressure + squeeze pressure from a collar

    Shock (which is intended to be painful) and stimulation (which is intended to be a gentle tactile sensation) are two different things.

    While Halo pet collar did NOT pioneer modern stimulation like what is used in E-Collar technologies e-collars, they are using stimulation (not shock) in the Halo, Halo 2, and Halo 3 collar. Modern stimulation collars are the ONLY kind we recommend, so Halo gets 5 stars from us for this!

    6

    Halo Dog Containment Systems Reviews – What is the Halo Dog Collar?

    The Halo, Halo 2, and Halo 3 Dog collar is an automated E-Collar. It uses sound, vibration, and electronic stimulation to teach and reinforce invisible boundaries. This can keep your dog safe while off-leash!

    Imagine this. You create a virtual fence using the Halo App on your phone. In this example, you might draw a map that is meant to keep your dog on your front lawn.

    As your dog approaches the boundary of the edge of the lawn, the collar lets the dog know that they are nearing it. If the dog chooses to disregard the first communication, the collar can use stimulation (a form of pressure) to discourage continued movement towards the boundary. It will then reward them for turning away from the boundary (back onto your lawn, yay!).

    From what we understand, the user has a lot of control over how corrections are implemented and used. This is very helpful because every dog is different!

    The collar will, with training, keep your dog inside of that invisible fence. This could be very helpful technology! We definitely like the concept.

    If your dog gets out of the boundary that you set, despite warnings and corrections, a feature it built in that will allow you to find your dog with the included GPS tracker. This is a nice feature.

    The Halo collar retails for nearly $1000 (yes, you read that correctly!) but is occasionally seen offered at around $699.

    2023 Update: The Halo 3 has been released with updates to the GPS capabilities and overall build.

    12 1

    Is There a Monthly Fee for the Halo Collar?

    Yes, there is a monthly fee associated with the Halo Collar app.

    We have noticed that it’s something many buyers are VERY surprised by!

    The monthly fees to use the required app are an additional cost. Without a paid monthly subscription, the features of the Halo Dog Collar are very limited.

    The Cesar dog collar comes in two colors and three sizes; the largest size Collar expands to 30.5″ and may or may not fit a giant breed dog. Measure your dogs neck before ordering!

    Now, if you have spent any time on our site, you know that we support ethical, positive, and humane E-Collar use.

    We are not going to have any issue at all with the concept of the Halo Collar as an electric training device. Keeping a dog safe by using tactile electric communication is one of the most gentle, humane, and responsible things dog owners can do.

    16 1

    How Well Does the Halo Collar Work?

    The idea behind the Halo Collar is that it automates boundary training. It’s kind of like a modern ‘invisible fence’.

    The Halo marketing department focuses heavily on this tool easily giving dogs off-leash freedom anywhere you go. How cool would it be to go camping, and be able to keep your pup on your campsite?

    It’s important to note that all training devices require diligent training and conditioning. The Halo, Halo 2, and Halo 3 are no exception. Do not expect to put this collar on your dog and be quickly and easily safely off leash anywhere you go.

    Because it works on GPS and a phone APP, your dog’s safety relies on the system not experiencing a technical failure of some kind.

    As with ANY training tool, it also relies on your ability to follow the training instructions and work with your dog on a regular basis.

    If the Halo 3 collar gps system is functioning and you’ve spent time teaching your dog how to respond to the communications from the Halo Collar, it can absolutely work beautifully!

    Screen Shot 2023 10 24 at 11.45.52 AM
    The Halo Dog Collar by Cesar Milan

    People are Talking: Real-Life Halo Dog Collar Reviews

    Unfortunately, there have reports from people that their smart off-leash dog collar has broken, stopped functioning, doesn’t work, and is cheaply made.

    A lot of people on Youtube cite that the original Halo collar is made primarily of weak plastic parts which may fail and leave your dog unprotected. Halo made improvements to their dog off-leash collar with the Halo 2, and we are optimistic that the Halo 3 is a game changer!

    JUNE 2022 UPDATE: We’ve read that Halo has supposedly completely fixed and updated many reported issues.

    If you are looking to purchase a Halo Collar for your dog, you should in theory feel much more confident in the newer model. We are giving this some time before updating our review with information about the quality and consistency of the newer version.

    11

    GPS Automation Failures on the Halo Wireless Fence

    There have been some reports out there that the GPS aspect of the collar, on the original and currently updated version, can at times be unreliable. This is largely related to the nature of technology and GPS.

    Unreliable electronics and poor use of corrections are a massive reason that we never advocate for the use of cheap shock collars (remember, a properly used E-Collar is different).

    Normally we say to stay away from cheap shock collars….but this device isn’t cheap! We believe that a solid amount of technology and research has gone into this device.

    Screen Shot 2023 10 24 at 11.50.59 AM

    How the Halo Dog Training Collar Works

    IF the Halo collar is actually functioning properly with a strong, reliable GPS connection to the ‘fence’ you built in the app, you do still have to work on training.

    Don’t be made to believe that this is an ‘easy fix’ to a well-trained dog.

    Proper conditioning and training are important with any training tool, including harnesses, so this is to be expected. However, this training should be fun and easy!

    The Cesar dog collar functions by using a tone or audible voice and then static (muscle stimulation) to remind dogs to turn away from a boundary.

    The company does say you have to train your dog how to respond to the collar, and the app walks you through the process. It’s automated, but not automatic.

    Once your dog understands how to respond to the communication from the collar, you should be able to draw a boundary and have your dog understand it, almost anywhere that you go.

    The collar will issue sounds, verbal communications, and static stimulation as needed to direct your dog into the boundary.

    7

    Is the Halo Collar Worth It?

    The price of the Halo Dog Collar is premium, there is no question about that. For some dog owners, this is cost prohibitive. A simple long leash can accomplish a similar thing for much, much less.

    As before, we are hopeful that recent updates to their device will give millions of dogs a valuable opportunity to be off-leash! The Halo Collar may be the ideal solution for you if:

    • You don’t have a fence
    • You regularly visit people where there is no fence
    • You like to go camping and want your dog to stay within a boundary of the tent site
    • You want a simple, user-friendly training tool
    • You don’t mind automating parts of your off-leash training
    • You have a dog that likes to learn, likes to be near you and already has a least a basic recall
    • Your pet is not reactive or aggressive, or has reactivity that is well managed
    Halo dog collar review

    SUMMARY

    Now that you’ve read our Halo Dog Collar review, would you buy one?

    Do we think you should buy a Halo dog collar?

    Do we believe that the Halo 3 for Dogs is a solid update to what was previously a somewhat unreliable product?

    I am optimistic in my belief that the Halo Dog Collar is a great choice for many pet owners. We LOVE that they no longer focus so much on their relationship with Cesar Milan (a very controversial dog trainer), and that they are continually improving their products.

    The main reason we’d recommend a HALO collar is for people who cannot build a physical fence around their property and want something slightly more flexible than a traditional invisible fence.

    7 1

    Halo Dog Treats Reviews

    Are Halo dog treats legit? Some people confuse the Halo Collar with the Halo dog food and dog treats company.

    We do not recommend Halo Dog food, but the treats may be ok!

  • E-Collar Myths – Great Dane Training

    E-Collar Myths – Great Dane Training

    Many people view E-Collars (sometimes called ‘shock collars) as an ‘Easy button’ meant to startle and punish a dog that is acting out. This is labeled as ‘aversive’ training and rightfully so.

    The belief that this is how all E-Collars are used is unfortunately what gives E-Collars a BAD name, however. It’s important to note that a heavy-handed, aversive, forceful punishment-based approach is the exact opposite of how an E-Collar should be used.

    Today we are dispelling some common MYTHS about E-Collars and E-Collar training, so that you can make an informed decision. 

    MYTH # 1: SHOCK COLLARS AND E-COLLARS ARE THE SAME THING

    E-Collars and Shock collars look similar but they are very, very different tools.

    You can read our blog post on this topic by clicking HERE.

    E-Collars provide a blunt, tactile  muscle stimulation that feels like ants marching or a gentle tingle, and 100 levels to choose from.

    EASY Educator collar

    Shock collars provide a sharp static correction is meant to HURT, with only a few levels to choose from.

    If your goal is to hurt, startle, scare or intimidate your dog like they did back in 2001 I suppose a shock collar will work just fine. But shock collars SUCK. They deserve their sketchy reputation.

    Proper E-Collars run $180 or MORE. They cannot be compared to or used the same way as cheap garbage shock collars from Amazon.
    Read on…

    MYTH #2: E-COLLARS MAKE DOGS FEARFUL AND ANXIOUS

    Incorrectly used shock collars can absolutely make a dog fearful, anxious or even aggressive.

    But so can incorrectly used head harnesses, no-pull harnesses, squirt bottles, crates and even LEASHES!

    Every single training tool, including those often labeled as ‘positive’ can be harmful or hurtful to a dog if used incorrectly.

    Confusing, punishment based restrictive training methods including intimidation and ‘Alpha/Dominance’ are what lead to fear, anxiety and aggression.

    The tactile communication from a properly used E-Collar is more gentle than the tactile communication from a leash, no-pull harness, head collar, or tension on the neck from pulling.

    That’s a fact, and one that tends to surprise a lot of people.

    MYTH #3: E-COLLARS ARE EXTREMELY AVERSIVE

    Let’s compare a popular ‘positive’ dog training tool to a properly used E-Collar.

    HEAD COLLAR. Head collars cause many dogs to paw, whine, become frantic or shut down.
    It is a rare dog who will accept a head collar without having a problem with it straight out of the gate. Halti and Gentle Leaders rely on tactile pressure, even just by being worn.

    Head collars require counter-conditioning and desensitization that often takes days or weeks. The dog will always experience constant pressure from the head collar and may injure themselves if they pull or lunge against it, even just to sniff the ground.

    Head collars are considered a ‘friendly’ tool and are used by many ‘positive’ trainers despite the fact that they rely heavily on positive punishment and pressure.
    The same thing is true when it comes to front-clip and no-pull harnesses., which also rely on pressure/punishment and obstructing the way a dog moves. These are  NOT ‘positive’ or ‘force-free’ tools.

    E-COLLAR. E-Collars are introduced at a low level and paired with treats. Dogs do not shut down, become frantic or show signs of fear. Instead, they feel the stimulation and become very excited about it, all within minutes of being fully introduced to the tool! They know that the gentle stim = treats and good things.

    This gentle stimulation is a tactile/touch sensation that feels like tiny ants crawling on the skin and can be used to communicate to the dog that redirecting back to the handler and ignoring distractions that cause lunging, barking or pulling is always a good thing.

    I don’t know about you, but I’d MUCH rather feel a small occasional tingle (that I know how to respond to and know means good things when I do) than to spend my life restricted from natural movement with a long leash or a bunch of webbing clipped onto my chest or face.

    MYTH #4: YOU CAN’T USE AN E-COLLAR AND STILL CLAIM TO BE POSITIVE

    I suppose this is true if we are talking about those whom rely on shock, vibrate or high-level stim as an ‘easy button’ corrective tool.

    We don’t support such unethical E-Collar use at all.

    Slapping an electric collar on a dog and using it straight up as a corrective tool is NOT humane, ethical, positive or appropriate. We agree!

    In the last decade, HUGE strides have been made in dog training and the modern E-Collar is not used that way AT ALL. 

    Basically put, dog trainers, dog owners and rescues who believe that all E-Collar training involves zapping a dog every time it reacts or steps out of line are uneducated about E-Collar training and unwilling to have an open mind about it. 

    The trainers who are doing E-Collar training correctly include people such as Larry Krohn and Tyler Muto, who use a hugely positive approach (lots of treats, praise, games and confidence building) and teach the E-Collar as a communication tool for off-leash reliability, not a correction tool.

    They believe, as we do, that all foundational skills must first be taught without the E-Collar: sit, down, leave it, drop it, wait, come, place, stay and touch. 

    217680192 184856893623872 170816817776630101 n

    They also believe that it is completely inappropriate to ‘light a dog up‘ for emotional and fear based reactivity, including barking, lunging, aggression and leash aggression. 

    Run from any trainer who tells you to use the E-Collar to teach basic behaviors and then use it to ‘correct’ them with stim for not complying. That is NOT appropriate E-Collar training and IS the reason why this tool has such a negative reputation.

    What does E-Collar training actually look like?

    The first step is to condition the dog to the stimulation, by teaching them that it means really, really good things. Remember, this stimulation, for a large majority of dogs (even big, powerful Danes) is less than most humans can feel! 

    Stim…treat. Stim…treat. Come…treat! Stim, Come….treat! YES!

    If you watch the body language of a dog being conditioned to an E-Collar, you see loose posture, wagging tail, eye contact, drive and excitement. After a few repetitions, they feel the stim and become VERY excited and run to the handler.

    Not unlike clicker training. Interesting. Unfortunately, MANY unethical trainers and uneducated dog owners completely skip the conditioning step and see the tool as a correction device for frustrating behaviors, and that’s unfortunate. 

    When done correctly, the E-Collar becomes the leash and in many ways, is less aversive, less restrictive, and less harmful than a leash (especially if the dog pulls or lunges). In the first session with the E-Collar, most dogs learn quickly that stim = follow/come/be with me and they LOVE IT.

    No leash pressure, no tension, no stress on the neck, chest or shoulders. The dog is free to move naturally and is simply asked, through a gentle stimulation and treats, to be responsive to the handler. They are not being corrected or punished, either.

    It’s interesting how that is considered ‘forceful’ and damaging. We believe it’s simply ignorance and a lack of education, or people who prefer to outright judge,  have a closed mind and are unwilling to learn about this. 

    MYTH #5: E-COLLARS HURT THE DOG

    Modern E-Collars (view them here) have 100 levels of stimulation that can be increased incrementally.

    Most dogs respond to stimulation levels of 10 or less.

    For perspective, it’s important to understand that most humans cannot even feel the stimulation until it’s been set at a level of 12 or higher. 

    A stimulation level of 6 or 7 is almost imperceptible. The sensation is so gentle that it is completely non-aversive. If it were hurting the dog, the dog being trained would show signs of stress. If a dog shows signs of stress while being trained, something is not being done correctly. 

    At worst, the stimulation from an E-Collar may be seen as mildly annoying to the dog. Which, a harness, leash, long line, head collar or keeping a door shut until the dog sits calmly may produce the same feelings.

    The dog knows (through conditioning) how to quickly get rid of the tingling sensation. They are in control and can easily get rid of the ‘annoying’ thing. They also know that getting rid of it means treats and praise!

    That head collar or long leash though? There is nothing they can do about those.  They stay, whether the dog likes it or not.

    MYTH #6 – E-COLLARS ARE UNNECESSARY

    There is this idea out there that because a recall can be taught without an E-Collar, it should be and that there is no reason to add a tool to the mix.

    But the truth is, when done correctly, E-Collar trained dogs are enthusiastic, happy, calm and often offered more freedom and autonomy than many other dogs.
    How anybody can see that and say those dogs are abused is beyond us.

    The E-Collar is an invisible leash. It gives an extra step of security on top an already outstanding, positively trained recall. 

    So is it ‘necessary’? No. Is it extremely helpful and beneficial when it comes to safety and giving a dog additional freedom? YES.

    If a positive-only trained recall is blown off, there is no backup.

    The E-Collar is a great safety device. Positive-trained dogs would benefit from knowing and understand E-Collar stimulation for this reason. To go without is like riding without a seatbelt.

    The E-Collar provides a gentle, crystal clear communication to the dog from a distance, which ultimately allows for much more freedom. The tactile sensation can be used to communicate to a dog that it needs to come back, walk away from somebody else on the path, or has gone too far away. It can be used in an emergency, if the dog decides to chase a squirrel into traffic.

    A higher level of stimulation is less harmful in that last situation than if the dog were to hit the end of a long leash and be jammed up by the neck as a result. 

    This is especially true for dogs that need to move naturally and explore in order to feel enriched.

    ‘Shocking’ and punishing a dog for blowing off a recall is NOT HOW IT WORKS. Applying a gentle tactile stimulation that they know how to respond to (come back and it goes away) IS how it works.

    Interestingly enough, if you condition a dog correctly to the E-Collar, you rarely if ever have to use it. It’s not this ‘abusive’ tool of force that some people like to say it is. 

    146470348 881525432437065 3633916471720278105 n

    MYTH #7 – STUDIES SHOW E-COLLARS CAUSE STRESS

    Not a single one of those studies, that we’ve found, studied dogs where the dog was conditioned to the E-Collar first and trained with a lot of positive reinforcement.

    Shock and startle training will absolutely cause stress. Cheap shock collars CAUSE STRESS. Stimming dogs for messing up, especially when they don’t know what’s being asked of them,  will CAUSE STRESS.

    Many of those studies lump shock collars and E-Collars together as the same tool; which they aren’t. The studies are not peer-reviewed. They are often biased and always extremely flawed.

    Yet, people continue to cite them…even trainers who claim to be ‘science-based’.  There is nothing science-based about citing studies that were not correctly done.

    Watch this video of Larry Krohn conditioning a dog to the E-Collar. Please send us an email and tell us where this dog is stressed, anxious or being forced.

    MYTH #8: VIBRATE IS BETTER THAN ‘SHOCK’

    Most shock collars and E-Collars come with a ‘vibrate’ function.

    Many dog owners believe that ‘vibrate’ is a gentle way to correct their dog, and will proudly state that they use that and would ‘never use shock unless necessary’.

    Remember, we believe that shock collars are absolute garbage. So yeah, shocking a dog is not ok. That’s not E-Collar training and shock and startle is not the most effective training, either.

    Newsflash, though…vibrate mode is super-duper aversive to most dogs.

    Does it succeed in punishing a dog for a behavior? Yup. Does it redirect dogs? Sure. Does it make owners feel ‘good’ about using it? Unfortunately, yes.

    Take your vibration collar and put it in the palm of your hand to experience it. Have somebody else randomly hit the vibrate button when you aren’t paying attention.  It’s really annoying and startling.

    Take a PROPER E-Collar (like the Educator series) and put it on a level 7 (average stim where most dogs enthusiastically work). Feel it on your body somewhere. Heck, bump it up to a 14 and try again.

    Tell me which YOU would prefer.

    Folks, vibration mode is bad. 

    READY TO GET STARTED?

    We rely heavily on positive reinforcement AND we use E-Collars to give our dogs security in their off-leash adventures.

    Hello Danes is an authorized distributor of E-Collar Technologies products, and we are here to help you train your Great Dane in a positive, ethical way. Imagine off-leash freedom and more.

    Let’s do this! Shop our collection of high-quality E-Collars for Great Danes here, and use code ECOLLARMAGIC for $10 off. Our E-Collars ship directly from the manufacturer.